An artist's rendering of a proposed affordable housing development in Astoria called Copeland Commons. (Morgan Heim)

The Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries has reversed itself on the matter of requiring prevailing wages on some residential developments.

In 2025, BOLI told a developer of a proposed conversion of a vacant Astoria hotel into a 64-unit affordable housing complex that it would have to pay prevailing, i.e., union-scale, wages on the project. That ruling increased the cost by $2.5 million and halted the development.

Now, 22 months later, BOLI has reversed itself, following a ruling earlier this fall by the Oregon Court of Appeals. As a result, Astoria will get dozens of badly needed new apartments. And it should now become easier statewide to convert empty offices, dormant churches, and vacant schools into affordable housing.

BOLI has a lot of authority over the construction of subsidized affordable housing in Oregon. Whenever a developer gets public funding for a project, BOLI decides whether the developer must pay prevailing wages. The agency’s determination carries high stakes for developers because union wages can add 10% to 20% to a project’s cost.

Oregon law states that affordable housing projects, generally, are exempt from prevailing wage requirements. But developers say that under Labor Commissioner Christina Stephenson, elected in 2022 and reelected this year, BOLI has regularly required prevailing wages on projects that developers believe should be exempt.

BOLI Commissioner Christina Stephenson won elections in 2022 and 2026 with strong trade union support. (Courtesy of BOLI)

In the case of the Astoria development, BOLI ruled that converting a vacant structure into affordable housing would require paying prevailing wages. In writing about the stalled conversion last year, OJP held it up as an example of how the agency’s legal interpretations can slow projects, make them more expensive, or kill them outright, all while Oregon battles the nation’s second-highest rate of homelessness, trailing only New York.

The Astoria project, called Copeland Commons, dates back to 2019. Bill Van Nostran, a since retired minister at Astoria’s First Presbyterian Church, wanted to combat Clatsop County’s rate of homelessness, Oregon’s highest. He formed a nonprofit and purchased the State Hotel, a four-story downtown building that had stood largely vacant for more than 50 years.

But in January 2025, as Van Nostran’s group moved toward construction, BOLI told his development team that although the building conversion would create new apartments, the project did not meet the definition of “residential construction” and therefore would have to pay prevailing wages.

In a state where trade unions carry enormous sway with the BOLI commissioner, Gov. Tina Kotek and the Democratic supermajorities in both legislative chambers, Van Nostran was outgunned.

An attorney for affordable housing developers argued in a June 2024 memo to Kotek that Stephenson’s agency was contributing to the state’s housing shortage. 

“BOLI has become increasingly predisposed to interpreting Oregon statutes and administrative rules in a manner that subjects projects to prevailing wage rate laws,” Dina Alexander wrote. “BOLI consistently looks for any reason” to require projects to pay prevailing wages “with little regard for legal rationale or larger policy questions.”

Van Nostran’s team appealed BOLI’s decision late last year. The bureau, which acts as first arbiter of its own decisions, rejected the appeal. OJP reported that the agency insisted the project would have to pay union wages.

Bill Van Nostran conceived the idea of converting an old hotel into housing. It’s been difficult. (Morgan Heim)

But on Election Day, Nov 3., BOLI did a 180-degree turn and informed Van Nostran it had changed its earlier finding. The reason? In September, the Oregon Court of Appeals, ruling on a similar dispute over a Salem affordable housing project that BOLI said required prevailing wages, found the agency had misinterpreted the law.

“The Legislature intended for the [prevailing wage] exemption to cover affordable housing, regardless of whether it uses some materials from a previous building,” the court wrote. “BOLI’s interpretation is contrary to the Legislature’s intent.”

The court’s ruling set a precedent that prompted BOLI to change its finding on Van Nostran’s project. 

Based on the new Court of Appeals decision, BOLI Commissioner Stephenson wrote to Van Nostran’s group that “prevailing wage rate laws do not apply to projects for residential construction that are privately owned and that predominantly provide affordable housing.”

Van Nostran felt vindicated. “The permission NOT to pay prevailing wages should save us approximately $2.5 million in construction costs,” he told OJP. 

Van Nostran credited OJP’s coverage of BOLI’s earlier ruling with bringing needed attention to the matter. That coverage, he said, “created quite a stir—both locally, as well as in Portland and, perhaps, around the state.”

BOLI spokeswoman Rachel Mann said her agency simply responded to the Court of Appeals’ decision. 

“BOLI’s actions in this case reflect the agency’s proactive commitment to ensuring that its pending determinations are informed by the most recent and applicable legal authority when they are issued,” Mann said. 

State Sen. Dick Anderson (R-Lincoln City), vice chair of the Senate Housing Committee, said he’s pleased Astoria will get new housing but also frustrated BOLI stood in the way in the first place. 

“Copeland Commons never should have been a fight,” Anderson told OJP. “The Legislature wrote this exemption for exactly this kind of project, and it took a Court of Appeals ruling to get a Democratic state agency to follow it.” 

Anderson introduced Senate Bill 1566 earlier this year to clarify prevailing wage laws and speed up construction of more and cheaper affordable housing. He said next year’s legislative session will test whether the Democrats who control Salem care about solving Oregon’s homelessness crisis. 

Even after the Court of Appeals ruling on renovation, there is still significant disagreement over how prevailing wage law affects other affordable housing projects. The first issue is whether new affordable housing projects financed by the state’s Local Innovation and Fast Track program, which provides hundreds of millions annually, require prevailing wages.

A second: whether the construction of public infrastructure triggers prevailing wages on adjacent private projects. As OJP has reported, BOLI’s position that it does has stalled a major development in Eugene. 

Anderson said it’s time for the Legislature to give BOLI clear instructions that match the urgency of the state’s homelessness crisis. 

“Housing providers shouldn’t have to sue to get the law applied as written,” Anderson said. “In 2027, I will bring this fix [SB 1566] back and Democratic leaders will have to decide whether they stand with working families who need homes—or keep standing in the way.”

Nigel Jaquiss is OJP’s senior investigative reporter and the most decorated journalist in Oregon history. He was awarded the 2005 Pulitzer Prize for Investigative Reporting for his work at Willamette...